CLBCLTR.
News

Marco Carola, Amnesia and the €2.4M Ibiza Club Dispute

Marco Carola, Amnesia and the €2.4M Ibiza Club Dispute

CLUB FILES / IBIZA ARCHIVE · Events from 2019, court ruling from 2022

In 2019, Marco Carola took Music On from Amnesia to Pacha after seven years at the former Ibiza club. What appeared to be a residency switch became a legal dispute involving exclusivity, an injunction and millions of euros in competing claims.

But the most eye-catching figure, €2.4 million, was not a fine a court ordered Carola to pay for playing a night at Pacha. The contracts, parties and eventual judgment tell a more complicated story.

The move that triggered the dispute

Music On had run at Amnesia since 2012. Carola announced the move to Pacha for the 2019 season, despite objections linked to existing agreements. A court in Ibiza issued a temporary restriction on his performances elsewhere on the island.

Carola still played Pacha on 16 May 2019. A week later, the Balearic public broadcaster IB3 reported that he had appeared in court over the alleged breach of the temporary order.

Where the millions came from

There were two connected but distinct contractual disputes. Amnesia’s operating company sought a €2.4 million contractual penalty from Carola’s former promoter, It’s All About The Music. Separately, that promoter sought approximately €4.38 million in damages from Carola and associated companies.

Those were claims, not confirmed payments or court awards. The distinction matters: headlines about a €2.4 million “fine” can make it sound as though that amount was imposed on Carola personally. The published judgment does not say that.

What the appeals court actually ordered

On 5 September 2022, the Balearic Islands appeals court ruled on the promoter’s case. It found that Carola had ended their verbal promotion agreement without sufficient justification and assessed €1,484,390.70 in lost profits, limited to 2019.

The court then offset €520,000 in unpaid fees and €429,630.89 in further sums owed to Carola and his companies. The resulting net amount ordered was €534,759.81, plus legal interest. The details are in the publicly accessible Judgment 419/2022.

That decision does not establish whether the sum was ultimately paid, nor does it resolve the separate Amnesia claim in the published record cited here.

The residency outlasted the headlines

Music On continued at Pacha, where the club still lists Carola and the residency. The episode is a reminder that the business behind the booth can be every bit as intense as the dancefloor.

And for a story that started with one DJ changing venues, the real plot twist was the accounting.

Sources and context: IB3 (23 May 2019); Balearic Islands Provincial Court, Judgment 419/2022 (5 September 2022); Music On; Pacha Ibiza. This article is a retrospective, not a report of newly filed proceedings.

Written byClub Culture

Leave a comment